Easy2Siksha.com
GNDU Question Paper-2021
Bachelor of Business Administration
B.B.A 1
st
Semester
Managerial Economics-l
Time Allowed: Three Hours Max. Marks: 50
Note: Attempt Five questions in all, selecting at least One question from each section. The
Fifth question may be attempted from any section. All questions carry equal marks.
SECTION-A
1. Explain the law of diminishing marginal utility. What are its limitations?
2. What do you mean by demand? Explain the law of demand with its limitations.
SECTION-B
3. What do you understand by Supply? Explain the law of supply and its limitations.
4. Explain the revealed preference approach in detail.
SECTION-C
5. Examine the law of variable proportions in detail.
6. Discuss the relationship between average and marginal revenue and price elasticity of
demand
Easy2Siksha.com
SECTION-D
7. What do you mean by perfect competition? Explain the equilibrium of firm under
perfect competition.
8. What is monopolistic competition? Explain the price and output determination under
monopolistic competition.
GNDU Answer Paper-2021
Bachelor of Business Administration
B.B.A 1
st
Semester
Managerial Economics-l
Time Allowed: Three Hours Max. Marks: 50
Note: Attempt Five questions in all, selecting at least One question from each section. The
Fifth question may be attempted from any section. All questions carry equal marks.
SECTION-A
1. Explain the law of diminishing marginal utility. What are its limitations?
Ans: Understanding the Law of Diminishing Marginal Utility
Imagine you are extremely thirsty on a hot summer day. You grab a cold bottle of water and
take a big sip. Ah! That first sip feels heavenly — refreshing and satisfying every bit of your
thirst. Now, you take a second sip. It still feels good, but maybe not as wonderful as the first.
Then the third sip, fourth sip, and so on — each sip gives you less pleasure than the one
before.
This everyday experience beautifully illustrates what economists call the Law of Diminishing
Marginal Utility. But what exactly does this law say? Let’s break it down in simple words.
Easy2Siksha.com
What is Utility?
First, a quick word about “utility.” Utility simply means the satisfaction or happiness you get
from consuming something. For example, the joy you get from eating your favorite
chocolate or watching a movie is your utility.
What is Marginal Utility?
Now, “marginal” means additional or extra. So, marginal utility is the additional satisfaction
you get from consuming one more unit of a good or service.
For example, if you eat one chocolate, the happiness from that one chocolate is your total
utility. If you eat a second chocolate, the happiness from that second chocolate — over and
above the first one — is the marginal utility of the second chocolate.
The Law of Diminishing Marginal Utility — The Simple Idea
The Law of Diminishing Marginal Utility says:
As you consume more units of a good or service, the additional satisfaction (marginal utility)
you get from each extra unit decreases.
In other words, the more you have of something, the less happy each extra unit makes you.
A Story to Understand the Law Better
Let me tell you a small story about Raju, a college student.
Raju loves mangoes — especially during the summer. One day, he buys five ripe mangoes
from the market. Let’s see how he feels as he eats them one by one:
• First mango: Raju is super hungry and hasn’t eaten all day. The first mango tastes
heavenly. He feels extremely satisfied and happy. The marginal utility of this first
mango is very high.
• Second mango: Raju is still enjoying the mangoes, but the excitement is slightly less
than the first. The second mango tastes good, but the happiness from it is less than
the first mango.
• Third mango: Now Raju starts feeling full. The third mango tastes okay, but it doesn’t
give him much joy. The marginal utility is lower now.
• Fourth mango: He is quite full and feels a little tired of eating mangoes. The fourth
mango gives very little happiness.
Easy2Siksha.com
• Fifth mango: By now, Raju is too full to eat more. The fifth mango might even feel
like a burden, or worse, he might feel discomfort. The marginal utility might be zero
or even negative!
Why Does This Happen?
The reason this happens is that human wants are generally satiable. We want things, but
after some point, we get full or bored or lose interest, so the additional benefit from more
of the same thing goes down.
Graphical Explanation (If Needed)
If you were to plot a graph, the total utility (the total happiness from all mangoes) would
rise as Raju eats more mangoes but at a slower rate each time. The marginal utility curve
(the extra happiness from each additional mango) would slope downwards, showing the
diminishing nature.
Real-Life Examples
• Eating slices of pizza: The first slice tastes amazing. The second is still good, but less
exciting. By the third or fourth slice, you might feel too full and the happiness from
each slice drops.
• Watching episodes of a TV show: The first episode is thrilling, but watching the
tenth episode in a row may bore you.
Why is this Law Important?
This law helps economists and businesses understand consumer behavior — why people
don’t buy unlimited quantities of something even if it tastes good or is desirable. It explains
why demand curves slope downwards — as price goes up, people buy less because the extra
satisfaction from more is low.
Limitations of the Law of Diminishing Marginal Utility
Though this law is widely accepted, it is not without its limitations. Let’s discuss these, so
you get a complete picture.
1. Not Applicable to All Goods
Easy2Siksha.com
There are exceptions. Some goods, especially luxury goods or collectibles, may not follow
diminishing marginal utility. For example:
• A collector may enjoy buying many rare stamps, each one giving him equal or more
satisfaction.
• For some people, utility might even increase with each additional unit because of
prestige or status.
2. Utility is Subjective and Hard to Measure
Utility is a psychological feeling — it cannot be measured objectively like weight or length.
Different people get different satisfaction from the same thing. So, marginal utility varies
from person to person.
3. Time Factor Ignored
The law assumes that all units are consumed at the same time or in a short time frame. But
if you consume units over a long time, marginal utility might not diminish as quickly. For
example, eating one chocolate today and another after a week might give similar
satisfaction.
4. Addictive Goods
For addictive goods (like cigarettes or drugs), marginal utility might increase initially because
of addiction, going against the law.
5. Variety and Change in Taste
If a product changes in quality or variety, or if the consumer’s tastes change, marginal utility
might not diminish as predicted.
6. Saturation Point is Not Always Clear
Sometimes it is hard to define when marginal utility becomes zero or negative. For example,
how many cups of tea will make you stop enjoying it? This varies widely.
Summing Up Like a Story’s End
Think of the law of diminishing marginal utility as a tale about human satisfaction — it tells
us that happiness from things we consume does not grow endlessly. Like the refreshing
Easy2Siksha.com
water that quenches thirst but eventually loses its magic after many sips, or the mangoes
Raju loves but cannot eat forever — each additional piece brings less joy.
But remember, just like stories have twists, so does this law. Sometimes, things don’t follow
the rule, like when a rare stamp collector’s excitement grows with every new stamp or when
addiction plays a strange game with our satisfaction.
Understanding this law helps us make smarter choices — from the way businesses price
their products to how we manage our own desires.
If you imagine your life as a book, the Law of Diminishing Marginal Utility is like the chapter
that teaches us to appreciate things in moderation, to savor the first bites and sips more
than the endless consumption that might leave us tired or bored.
2. What do you mean by demand? Explain the law of demand with its limitations.
Ans: Dawn in the Marketplace: Unveiling Demand and Its Law
Before the sun broke over the sandstone walls of Jaipur, Meera, a textile trader, arranged
her colorful cloth bolts by price. As customers trickled in, she noticed a pattern: when she
slightly lowered a bolt’s price, more people paused, touched the fabric, and bought. That
early revelation shaped her understanding of demand—the heartbeat of every market. Let’s
journey through this concept, explore the law that governs it, and examine the moments
when the rule bends.
Defining Demand
Demand is more than a mere desire for goods or services. It represents the willingness and
ability of consumers to purchase specific quantities at various prices during a given time.
Here are its key elements:
• Willingness: Consumers must want the product.
• Ability: They need purchasing power, such as money or credit.
• Price and Time: Demand is tied to specific prices and time periods.
So when Meera saw her cloth flying off the stall only after a price cut, she was witnessing
true demand in action.
The Law of Demand
The law of demand states that, all else being equal, quantity demanded of a good falls as its
price rises, and quantity demanded rises as its price falls.
In simple terms:
• Price up → Demand down
Easy2Siksha.com
• Price down → Demand up
This inverse relationship between price and quantity demanded holds because:
• Substitution effect: Consumers switch to cheaper alternatives if a price rises.
• Income effect: A higher price reduces purchasing power, shrinking the amount
bought.
When Meera halved the price on pastel silks, busy housewives suddenly saw them as
affordable luxuries, boosting her sales.
Story 1: The Market Stall Potato Paradox
Every afternoon, Ram operated a potato stall in Pune’s central bazaar. One sweltering
summer, potato prices doubled overnight due to a crop failure. Surprisingly, Ram’s sales
volume actually increased. Curious and worried, he dug deeper and discovered that poorer
families, facing wheat price hikes, used potatoes as a cheaper staple. In this odd case, higher
potato prices meant even greater demand. This puzzling exception highlights that while the
law of demand generally holds, unusual conditions can flip its effect.
Visualizing the Law of Demand
Economists often illustrate this relationship with a downward-sloping demand curve on a
graph:
As you move right (higher quantity), the curve slopes down (lower price). This visual
reinforces that consumers buy more when prices drop.
Determinants of Demand
While price is a primary driver, other factors shift demand curves:
• Income levels: Higher incomes usually increase demand for normal goods.
• Consumer tastes: Trends and preferences can tilt demand.
• Prices of related goods: Substitutes and complements influence choices.
• Expectations: Anticipations of future price changes affect current buying.
• Population demographics: More buyers raise total market demand.
When Meera heard silk sarees trending after a celebrity wedding, she stocked those hues,
expecting demand to surge regardless of small price hikes.
Easy2Siksha.com
Limitations and Exceptions to the Law of Demand
Reality introduces quirks that break the neat inverse rule. Here are the major limitations:
1. Giffen Goods • Inferior goods where a price increase makes them appear scarcer
and more necessary, leading to higher consumption (like Ram’s potatoes).
2. Veblen Goods • Luxury items whose demand rises with price because the high cost
signals status (designer handbags, luxury watches).
3. Necessities with No Close Substitutes • Essential medicines or utilities may see
stable demand even when prices climb.
4. Expectations of Future Price Changes • If consumers expect prices to rise further,
they buy more now, temporarily defying the law.
5. Multi-Use Goods • Products serving diverse purposes (smartphones, printing paper)
can have demand patterns that ignore small price shifts.
6. Quality Perception • A lower price might signal inferiority, pushing demand down
even when cheaper.
7. Complementary Goods Effect • Demand for one good depends on another. If
gasoline prices soar, demand for cars may fall even if car prices drop.
These exceptions remind us that human behavior and market contexts can twist simple
economic rules.
Story 2: The Designer Watch Phenomenon
In Mumbai’s glitzy boutiques, Arjun noticed a new trend: as the price of a particular Swiss
watch climbed, its reservation list lengthened. Customers believed that only exclusive
buyers could afford it, boosting its prestige. Here, price didn’t deter demand—it fueled it.
Arjun’s insight led him to source a similarly positioned brand, leveraging the Veblen effect to
grow his luxury watch segment.
Shifting Demand vs. Movement along Demand
Understanding demand means distinguishing two ideas:
• Movement along the demand curve: Caused by price changes of the same good (our
core law of demand).
• Shift of the entire demand curve: Due to non-price factors (income, tastes, etc.).
When Meera’s neighborhood gained a new office hub, lunchtime snack demand jumped at
every price, shifting her demand curve rightward, not just moving along it.
Practical Implications for Businesses
Grasping demand and its quirks arms entrepreneurs with strategic decisions:
Easy2Siksha.com
• Price Setting • Use price elasticity estimates to maximize revenue. If demand is
elastic, small price changes yield big sales swings.
• Product Positioning • Identify if your product acts like a Giffen or Veblen good and
adjust marketing accordingly.
• Inventory Management • Monitor demand shifts tied to seasons, trends, and
competitor actions to avoid shortages or overstock.
• Promotion Timing • Launch discounts when demand is sluggish, and scarcity
campaigns when demand is surging.
Through sharp demand analysis, Meera timed her saree promotions right before festive
seasons, optimizing both footfall and profits.
Wrapping Up the Story of Demand
Demand is the lifeblood of markets—a systematic reflection of consumers’ willingness and
ability to buy at different prices. The law of demand provides a reliable compass, pointing to
the general inverse relationship between price and quantity demanded. Yet, as our stories
of potatoes in Pune and luxury watches in Mumbai show, real-world complexity can warp
the rule.
By recognizing when exceptions apply—whether through necessity, prestige, or shifting
expectations—businesses can navigate pricing and inventory strategies with finesse. For any
student or examiner, understanding demand isn’t just memorizing a downward curve; it’s
appreciating the human stories behind every market choice, and knowing when the rules
bend to reveal deeper insights.
So next time you haggle over a market stall price or see a designer item’s value rise with
cost, remember: demand is more than theory. It’s the dynamic dance between price,
preference, and perception—a dance that entrepreneurs must learn to lead.
SECTION-B
3. What do you understand by Supply? Explain the law of supply and its limitations.
Ans: A Dawn of Doughnuts: Discovering What Supply Truly Means
Before the sun peeked over the rooftops of Maplewood, Nina the baker was already up,
kneading dough in her small shop. As aromas of vanilla and sugar filled the air, she glanced
at the day’s orders: half a dozen dozen doughnuts at ₹20 each, and a special request for 100
glazed doughnuts at ₹30 apiece. With a satisfied nod, she knew exactly how many batches
to mix. This simple decision—deciding quantity based on price—captures the essence of
supply, the heartbeat of every marketplace.
What Is Supply?
Easy2Siksha.com
Supply represents the different quantities of a good or service that producers are willing and
able to offer for sale at various prices, over a given period of time, keeping all other factors
constant. In Nina’s case, her ability lies in her dough-kneading skills and oven capacity; her
willingness depends on whether the price covers her costs and earns her profit.
Key points in this definition:
• Willingness and Ability: Producers must want to sell and have the means to
produce.
• Price Dependence: Quantity supplied varies with price.
• Specific Time Frame: Supply reflects decisions for a day, a month, or a season.
• Ceteris Paribus: Other influences like technology or input costs remain unchanged
for the pure relationship.
Supply is not a single number—it’s a schedule or curve showing how Nina’s batches change
when doughnut prices rise or fall.
The Law of Supply
The law of supply states:
As the price of a good rises, the quantity supplied of that good increases, and as the price
falls, the quantity supplied decreases, all else held constant.
Why? Two economic forces drive this direct relationship:
1. Profit Incentive: Higher prices mean more revenue per unit sold. When doughnuts
fetch ₹30 instead of ₹20, Nina can cover extra costs—like overtime pay for helpers—
and still pocket more profit, motivating her to bake additional batches.
2. Marginal Cost Consideration: Each additional batch may cost slightly more—
premium ingredients, extra labor, or overtime electricity. To justify these rising
marginal costs, Nina requires higher selling prices.
Visualizing Supply
Economists plot the law of supply on a graph:
Easy2Siksha.com
The upward-sloping line (from left to right) reflects that higher prices (vertical axis) lead to
greater quantities supplied (horizontal axis).
Determinants of Supply
While price is primary, several non-price factors shift the entire supply curve:
• Cost of Production: Flour, sugar, and glaze prices. A spike in sugar cost makes Nina
bake fewer doughnuts at every price, shifting supply left.
• Technology and Productivity: A new mixer that doubles output with half the labor
can shift supply right—Nina can supply more doughnuts at the same price.
• Number of Sellers: If three new bakeries open in Maplewood, the collective supply
of doughnuts in the market rises.
• Government Policies: Subsidies on wheat flour lower input costs, boosting supply.
Conversely, a new bakery tax reduces Nina’s incentive, shrinking her output.
• Expectations of Future Prices: If Nina expects doughnut prices to surge tomorrow
(perhaps for Valentine’s Day), she might withhold batches today, reducing current
supply.
• Natural Factors and Disasters: A power outage or oven malfunction halts
production, constraining supply regardless of price.
These determinants shift supply curves; prices don’t. When input costs fall, supply shifts
right, meaning more doughnuts at every price level.
Story 2: The Farmer’s Vegetable Dilemma
In nearby Greenfield village, farmer Ravi grows tomatoes. One season, a processing plant
promised to pay ₹50 per kilogram for canning. Tempted by the high price, Ravi diverted half
his harvest to the plant, supplying 500 kg instead of his usual 200 kg to the fresh market. But
when the plant suddenly slashed prices to ₹30, Ravi reduced his canned tomato supply to
100 kg and redirected the rest to fresh markets. His shifting quantities perfectly mirror the
law of supply in action—and highlight how expectations and contract stability shape real
decisions.
Limitations of the Law of Supply
Though robust, the law of supply encounters real-world bumps and twists. Here are its key
limitations:
1. Time Lags and Production Constraints
o Some industries, like shipbuilding or aircraft manufacturing, take years to
adjust output. A sudden price jump won’t immediately translate into
increased supply. In Nina’s bakery, if she sells out of yeast, she can’t whip up
more doughnuts instantly—even if prices double.
Easy2Siksha.com
2. Perishable Goods
o Fresh produce, baked goods, and pharmaceuticals can’t all be stockpiled.
Bakers, farmers, and pharmacists can’t infinitely ramp up supply without
risking spoilage or expiry, decoupling supply from price in the short term.
3. Imperfect Information
o Producers may not know future market prices or demand. If Nina hears
rumors of a grain price surge next month, she may bake fewer doughnuts
today, even if today’s prices are high. Uncertainty disturbs pure price-supply
responses.
4. Capacity Limitations
o Factories and workshops have design capacities. Once ovens run at full tilt,
Nina can only expand supply by adding ovens—a capital-intensive, time-
consuming step. The law of supply presumes infinite scalability, which rarely
exists.
5. Government Controls and Quotas
o Price ceilings can force producers to limit supply despite high demand—like
rent-controlled flats. If local authorities cap doughnut prices at ₹15 to aid
low-income customers, Nina may rationally reduce output or withdraw from
the market.
6. Regulatory and Environmental Constraints
o Pollution limits, zoning laws, or labor regulations can curb production. A new
ordinance restricting bakery noise after 9 PM might truncate Nina’s late-night
runs, limiting her ability to ramp up supply for morning rushes.
7. Alternative Uses of Resources
o Inputs like flour or sugar can be diverted to other products—bread, pastries,
or jams. When prices of competing products spike, producers shift resources
away, altering supply of any single item in spite of its own price.
8. Stockpiling and Strategic Reserve
o For strategic or safety reasons, governments or firms may withhold supply. A
strategic grain reserve holds back wheat from the market to manage national
food security, defying short-term price signals.
9. Behavioral and Non-Economic Factors
o Producers might act on habits, brand loyalty, or ethical commitments rather
than purely profit motives. A baker who donates unsold doughnuts to charity
may supply more at low prices, contradicting straightforward price-supply
relationships.
Easy2Siksha.com
These limitations show that while the law of supply offers a foundational guideline, real
markets pulse with complexities that economists and entrepreneurs must navigate.
Weaving the Threads Together
Supply isn’t a static number; it’s a dynamic response to price signals and shifting
circumstances. From Nina’s bakery to Ravi’s tomato fields, producers constantly balance
production costs, resource constraints, and future expectations against prevailing prices.
• Law of Supply: Price up, quantity supplied up; price down, quantity supplied down.
• Determinants: Costs, technology, number of sellers, policies, expectations, and
external shocks.
• Limitations: Time lags, perishability, capacity caps, information gaps, regulations,
and strategic reserves.
For students, grasping supply means moving beyond memorizing an upward-sloping curve
to appreciating the real-world challenges—like yeast shortages, factory capacity constraints,
and policy shifts—that can bend and twist pure economic rules.
Final Takeaway
Supply shapes the availability of every product on our shelves and every service on demand.
Understanding its law and limitations empowers entrepreneurs to make smarter production
decisions and helps policymakers craft regulations that maintain fair, efficient markets. So
next time you bite into a freshly baked doughnut or buy a kilo of ripe tomatoes, remember
the intricate dance of supply—driven by price, but always influenced by the practical
realities of production.
4. Explain the revealed preference approach in detail.
Ans: The Tale of Sam and the Secrets of Choices: Understanding Revealed Preference
Approach
Imagine a young man named Sam who loves to buy things — snacks, books, clothes, and
gadgets. But Sam is a bit mysterious. Instead of telling you what he likes or prefers, he only
shows his preferences through his purchases. Every day, Sam goes to the market with some
money, chooses what to buy, and leaves. You never hear him say what he wants, but you
notice the things he picks up.
Now, as an observer, how do you figure out what Sam truly likes? You don’t need to ask him
directly. Instead, you watch what Sam buys when he faces different prices and budgets.
From his choices, you can start understanding his preferences. This is exactly what the
Revealed Preference Approach is all about!
What is the Revealed Preference Approach?
Easy2Siksha.com
The Revealed Preference Approach is a method in economics that helps us understand
people's preferences by looking at their actual choices rather than what they say. Instead of
asking consumers what they like (which might be biased or dishonest), economists watch
what consumers actually buy in the marketplace. The idea is: actions speak louder than
words.
So, if Sam buys chocolate over chips when both are available and affordable, we can
“reveal” that he prefers chocolate more than chips at that moment.
Why was Revealed Preference Approach invented?
Before this approach, economists mainly depended on asking people about their
preferences or assumed preferences based on theory. But asking people directly can be
tricky — people might not know their true preferences or might not be truthful.
So, an economist named Paul Samuelson introduced the Revealed Preference Approach in
1938 to avoid relying on what people say and instead focus on what people do. This made
economics more practical and realistic because real market choices give more reliable clues
about preferences.
How does Revealed Preference Work? (In Simple Terms)
Imagine this:
• One day, Sam has $10. He can buy either 2 chocolates or 4 packets of chips (each
chocolate costs $5, each chip packet costs $2.50).
• Sam chooses to buy 2 chocolates instead of 4 chip packets.
• Next week, chocolates are on discount and cost $4, and chips cost $3. Now, with
$10, Sam could buy 2 chocolates + 1 packet of chips or 3 packets of chips.
• This time, Sam buys 3 packets of chips instead.
What can you say about Sam’s preferences from these choices?
• When chips were cheaper relative to chocolates, Sam chose chips.
• When chocolates were cheaper, Sam chose chocolates.
Thus, Sam revealed his preferences by his choices given the prices and budget constraints.
The Key Idea: Preference Revealed by Choices Under Constraints
In economics, people have limited money — this is called a budget constraint. Given prices
and the amount of money they have, they pick the combination of goods that maximizes
their satisfaction (utility).
Easy2Siksha.com
If we observe a person choosing good A over good B when both are affordable, it means the
person prefers A to B. This is called direct revealed preference.
If the same person chooses good B over good C in another situation, then by transitivity, the
person prefers A to C. This is called indirect revealed preference.
This idea helps economists rank consumer preferences without ever asking them directly.
An Important Principle: The Weak Axiom of Revealed Preference (WARP)
To keep things consistent, economists use a rule called the Weak Axiom of Revealed
Preference. It says:
• If Sam chooses A when B was affordable, then Sam should never choose B when A is
affordable.
• If this happens, it means Sam’s choices are inconsistent.
For example, if Sam chooses chocolates over chips when both cost the same, but later
chooses chips over chocolates under similar conditions, it’s confusing. The Weak Axiom
helps identify such inconsistencies in choices.
Real-World Example: The Coffee-Shop Story
Let’s take a quick story:
There is a coffee shop where customers can buy coffee or tea. One day, coffee costs $3 and
tea costs $2. When both are affordable, most people buy tea. Another day, tea costs $3 and
coffee costs $2, and most people buy coffee.
By watching these choices, the coffee shop owner can reveal customer preferences and
decide how to price items or design combos. This helps the owner maximize sales and
satisfaction, showing the power of revealed preferences.
Advantages of Revealed Preference Approach
1. Based on actual behavior: It uses real choices, not just words or surveys.
2. Objective and reliable: Because people don’t always know or reveal their
preferences honestly, observing actual purchases is better.
3. No need for utility measurement: Economists don’t have to guess or assign numbers
to how much someone likes something.
4. Applicable in many situations: It helps understand market demand, consumer
welfare, and decision-making.
Easy2Siksha.com
Limitations of Revealed Preference Approach
• It assumes people always make rational choices, which might not be true in real life.
• Sometimes people’s choices are influenced by habits, peer pressure, or mistakes.
• It requires observing choices in different price and income situations to draw
conclusions.
• It can’t capture preferences for things people have never tried or bought.
Wrapping Up
So, just like a detective solves mysteries by following clues, economists solve the puzzle of
what people prefer by following the clues left by their purchases. The Revealed Preference
Approach is this detective’s tool. It reveals what people truly want by watching their actions,
not just listening to their words.
Remember Sam? By just watching him buy chocolates or chips at different prices, we
learned what he truly preferred. This is why the Revealed Preference Approach is powerful
and practical in economics — it helps us understand real human behavior in a simple,
straightforward way.
SECTION-C
5. Examine the law of variable proportions in detail.
Ans: The Law of Variable Proportions: An Easy and Enjoyable Explanation
Imagine you have a small kitchen garden. You start with a tiny plot where you plant some
tomatoes. To grow these tomatoes better, you decide to add more fertilizer, water, and
plant some extra seeds in the same plot. But you only have a limited area of land.
At first, adding more fertilizer and planting more seeds might help you get more tomatoes.
But after some time, no matter how much fertilizer or seeds you add, the increase in
tomatoes slows down, and eventually, it might even hurt your harvest. Why does this
happen? This simple kitchen garden story is exactly what the Law of Variable Proportions
tries to explain.
What is the Law of Variable Proportions?
Easy2Siksha.com
The Law of Variable Proportions is a fundamental principle in economics that describes how
output changes when one input is increased while other inputs are kept constant. Simply
put:
• When you increase one factor of production (like labor, fertilizer, or seeds), keeping
other factors (like land or machinery) fixed, the total output will change in a specific
way.
• Initially, output increases at an increasing rate, then at a decreasing rate, and
eventually may even decrease.
This law applies mostly in the short run, when some inputs are fixed and others are variable.
Why is this Law Important?
This law helps farmers, manufacturers, and business owners understand how to use their
resources efficiently. It tells them when adding more of one input (like labor or fertilizer) will
be profitable and when it will stop making sense.
The Three Phases of the Law of Variable Proportions
Let’s break down the story with your kitchen garden as the example to explain the three
phases of this law:
Phase 1: Increasing Returns to the Variable Input
Imagine at first, you have only one worker watering your garden, and you add more
workers. The first few workers make a huge difference: more hands to water, weed, and
care for the plants. The number of tomatoes grows faster and faster because the extra
workers help use the fixed land and seeds better.
In economics terms: When you add more of the variable input (like labor), the total product
(total tomatoes) increases at an increasing rate. This means each new worker adds more to
output than the previous one. The marginal product (additional output from one more unit
of input) is rising, and the average product (output per worker) also increases.
Story moment: Think of it like a band performing on stage. At first, adding more musicians
creates a richer, fuller sound, and the audience loves it. But there’s a limit.
Phase 2: Diminishing Returns to the Variable Input
Now, you add even more workers to your same small plot of land. This time, the tomatoes
still increase, but the extra output per additional worker begins to slow down. Why?
Because the fixed land can only accommodate so many people — they start getting in each
other’s way. There’s less space to work efficiently, and the benefit of each new worker is
smaller than before.
Easy2Siksha.com
In economics terms: The total product keeps increasing, but at a decreasing rate. The
marginal product starts to fall but remains positive. The average product also starts to
decline after reaching a peak.
Story moment: Imagine your band is getting crowded on stage. The musicians bump into
each other, making it harder to play smoothly. The music is still good, but the extra quality
added by each new musician is less than before.
Phase 3: Negative Returns to the Variable Input
Finally, you keep adding workers to the tiny garden plot, far more than it can handle. Now,
instead of helping, they start harming the output. Some workers accidentally trample the
plants, others waste water or fertilizer, and the number of tomatoes actually falls.
In economics terms: Total product decreases, marginal product becomes negative, meaning
each new worker reduces overall output. This is called the phase of negative returns.
Summarizing the Law in Simple Words
• Add more input → Output grows fast (Increasing returns)
• Keep adding input → Output still grows but slower (Diminishing returns)
• Add too much input → Output falls (Negative returns)
Mathematical and Graphical View (Simple Version)
If we plot the total output against the variable input (like labor), the graph looks like a hill:
• The hill rises steeply in Phase 1.
• It rises gently and then flattens in Phase 2.
• Finally, it slopes down in Phase 3.
The marginal product curve first goes up, then down, and can become negative. The average
product curve rises and then falls.
Real-Life Example: The Lemonade Stand
To make it even clearer, imagine you run a lemonade stand:
• You start with one friend helping. You make 10 glasses of lemonade.
• You add a second friend, and production jumps to 25 glasses because they squeeze
lemons faster and serve customers quicker.
Easy2Siksha.com
• Adding a third friend increases production to 35 glasses, but the increase isn’t as
much as before because the stand is small.
• You add a fourth and fifth friend, but now they bump into each other, and you only
manage to make 38 glasses.
• With six friends, chaos breaks out; they spill lemons and knock over cups. You end up
making only 30 glasses.
This is exactly the law of variable proportions in action.
Why Does This Law Matter in Business?
Businesses use this law to decide:
• How many workers to hire.
• How much fertilizer to apply on a fixed land.
• When adding more input stops being profitable.
Ignoring this law can lead to wasted resources and losses.
Important Points to Remember
• The law applies only in the short run when at least one factor is fixed.
• It assumes technology remains constant.
• It shows the relationship between input and output.
• Helps in optimizing production for maximum efficiency.
Conclusion: The Tale of Efficient Resource Use
Think of the law of variable proportions as a wise gardener’s lesson: Using resources wisely
is like making a team work well. Too few, and you underperform; too many, and you get in
each other’s way. The best results come from finding just the right balance.
This law teaches us not to blindly add more inputs hoping for more output, but to
understand how things change with each additional input — making production smart,
efficient, and profitable.
Easy2Siksha.com
6. Discuss the relationship between average and marginal revenue and price elasticity of
demand?
Ans: The Art of Revenue: A Coffee Cart’s Tale
Before dawn breaks at Central Plaza, Maya wheels out her new artisan coffee cart. She’s
eyeing today’s special: a single-origin pour-over priced at ₹120. Last week, she sold 10 cups
at that price; this morning, she wonders what happens if she nudges the price up to ₹140.
Will selling fewer cups still boost her income? This simple question—balancing total takings
against extra earnings from each additional cup—reveals the dance between average
revenue, marginal revenue, and price elasticity of demand.
1. Defining the Key Players
Average Revenue (AR) is the revenue earned per unit sold. Calculated as
• AR = Total Revenue (TR) / Quantity Sold (Q)
If Maya sells 10 cups at ₹120, her total revenue is ₹1,200; AR equals ₹120.
Marginal Revenue (MR) is the additional revenue from selling one more unit. Formally:
• MR = ΔTotal Revenue / ΔQuantity
When Maya moves from selling 10 to 11 cups, MR measures the revenue difference
between ₹1,200 and whatever the 11th cup brings in.
Price Elasticity of Demand (ε) gauges how sensitive quantity demanded is to price
changes:
• ε = (% Change in Quantity Demanded) / (% Change in Price)
If her price hike from ₹120 to ₹140 trims demand from 10 cups to 8, elasticity is negative
and high (in absolute value), indicating a responsive market.
2. The Underlying Connections
2.1 AR and the Demand Curve
The average revenue curve is simply the firm’s demand curve expressed in revenue terms.
Every point on Maya’s demand curve—price versus quantity—tells her the AR at that output
level. If 10 cups sell at ₹120, AR(10) = ₹120. If lowering her price to ₹100 boosts sales to 15
cups, AR(15) = ₹100.
2.2 MR and Its Relation to AR
Marginal revenue tells Maya how her total revenue shifts when she sells an extra cup. Key
observations:
• When AR is constant (perfectly elastic demand), MR equals AR. If customers always
buy at ₹120, even if Maya increases output, each extra cup still brings ₹120. MR = AR
= ₹120.
Easy2Siksha.com
• When AR declines with higher output (downward‐sloping demand), MR falls faster
than AR. To sell an 11th cup, Maya may need to decrease price from ₹120 to ₹115
for every cup. That price cut reduces revenue on all units sold, so MR < AR.
Graphically, in monopoly or imperfect competition, the MR curve lies below the AR
(demand) curve.
3. Weaving in Elasticity
The precise link between MR, AR, and elasticity is fundamental. Economists derive:
Because elasticity ε is negative for normal downward‐sloping demand,
1
𝜀
is also negative.
Let’s unpack scenarios:
• Perfectly Elastic Demand (ε → –∞):
1
𝜀
approaches zero. MR = AR × (1 + 0) = AR. Here
Maya is a price‐taker; selling one more cup doesn’t force a price drop.
• Elastic Demand (|ε| > 1): Demand is sensitive. If ε = –2, then MR = AR × (1 – ½) = ½
AR. Maya’s extra cup brings half the average revenue because price cuts necessary
to sell more units dent earnings on existing cups.
• Unit Elastic Demand (ε = –1): MR = AR × (1 – 1) = 0. Total revenue is at its peak.
Raising or lowering price reduces revenue.
• Inelastic Demand (|ε| < 1): If ε = –0.5, MR = AR × (1 – 2) = –AR. Each additional cup
sells at a lower price that slices revenue more than the added unit brings in; MR is
negative.
4. Story 2: The Concert Ticket Conundrum
Later that month, Maya’s friend Jonas secures 500 tickets for his rock band’s stadium show.
He faces a dilemma: charge ₹2,000 or ₹2,500 per ticket? At ₹2,000, he expects to sell 400
tickets; at ₹2,500, maybe only 300.
• If he chooses ₹2,000, TR = 400 × ₹2,000 = ₹800,000; AR = ₹2,000; MR for the 401st
ticket would be ₹2,000 (assuming perfectly elastic segment) so MR = AR.
• If he hikes price to ₹2,500, TR = 300 × ₹2,500 = ₹750,000; AR = ₹2,500. But to push
from 300 to 301 tickets, he might have to lower price to ₹2,490 for all tickets,
slashing revenue on the original 300. The MR for ticket 301 would be
MR = (301 × ₹2,490) – 300 × ₹2,500 = ₹749, 0 – ₹750,000 = –₹1,000.
Here, demand proved inelastic—raising price shrank revenue and made MR negative. Jonas
learns that maximum revenue lies where MR = 0, aligning with unit elasticity.
5. Practical Insights
Easy2Siksha.com
5.1 Revenue Maximization
• Target MR = 0 to maximize total revenue.
• This corresponds to the point where demand is unit elastic (ε = –1).
5.2 Pricing Strategy
• When demand is elastic, cutting price can boost revenue because the increase in
quantity sold outweighs the price reduction. Maya might drop her coffee price from
₹120 to ₹110 if sales jump sufficiently.
• When demand is inelastic, raising price increases revenue. A rare specialty bean with
rabid fans allows Maya to push from ₹200 to ₹220, even if sales dip slightly, because
MR remains positive.
5.3 Market Structure Implications
• Perfect Competition Firms face perfectly elastic demand. AR = MR = price. They are
price takers; revenue curves are flat.
• Monopoly/Imperfect Competition Firms face downward‐sloping demand. MR curve
lies below AR. Pricing and output decisions hinge on elasticity: more elastic segments
justify output expansion; inelastic segments justify price hikes.
6. Graphical Glimpse
• AR: the downward‐sloping line showing price at each output.
• MR: steeper line beneath AR, intersecting the quantity axis where ε = –1.
7. Limitations and Real-World Twists
While the AR–MR–elasticity framework provides clarity, real markets add wrinkles:
• Price Discrimination: Charging different prices to segments with varying elasticities
can boost revenue beyond single‐price MR = 0.
• Dynamic Pricing: Online platforms adjust prices second by second based on real-
time demand elasticity, blurring static AR and MR curves.
Easy2Siksha.com
• Psychological Pricing: Perceived value, brand loyalty, and reference prices alter
elasticity and revenue responses.
• Capacity Constraints: In the short run, limited coffee beans or stadium seats make
MR jumps unpredictable.
8. Wrapping Up the Story
By dawn’s light, Maya thinks back to her first question: should she push her coffee price
higher? She calculates the elasticity of her morning rush and finds ε ≈ –1.5—elastic territory.
A slight price drop to ₹115 increases cups sold from 10 to 13, lifting total revenue from
₹1,200 to ₹1,495. Her marginal revenue per additional cup remains positive, and AR falls
only mildly, boosting profits.
She smiles, knowing she’s wielding economic principles as deftly as she brews her pour‐
over. Whether vending coffee or selling concert tickets, understanding the interplay of
average revenue, marginal revenue, and price elasticity gives any entrepreneur the edge in
crafting winning pricing strategies—turning every extra cup, ticket, or product into a story of
maximized revenue.
SECTION-D
7. What do you mean by perfect competition? Explain the equilibrium of firm under
perfect competition.
Ans: A Morning at Green Meadow Market: Discovering Perfect Competition
Before sunbeams lit the dewy pastures, Ravi, a wheat farmer, trundled his cart to Green
Meadow Market. Alongside dozens of other farmers, he laid out sacks of golden wheat. No
single farmer set the price—instead, the market’s invisible hand did. This bustling scene
captures the essence of perfect competition, where countless small sellers and buyers trade
identical goods at a single market price. Let’s walk through this world, uncover its defining
traits, and see how an individual firm finds its equilibrium amid endless peers.
What Is Perfect Competition?
Perfect competition describes a market structure where:
• There are many buyers and sellers, each too small to influence the market price
alone.
• The goods offered are homogeneous, meaning one seller’s product is
indistinguishable from another’s.
• Free entry and exit exist, so firms can enter when profits beckon and leave when
losses mount, without barriers.
Easy2Siksha.com
• Perfect information prevails—buyers and sellers know prices, costs, and product
quality at all times.
• There are no transaction costs, and resources move seamlessly across uses.
In Ravi’s wheat example, each farmer’s harvest is identical. Buyers compare prices across
dozens of sellers and pay the same rate, say ₹2,000 per quintal, because no seller can
demand more.
Key Characteristics of Perfect Competition
1. Numerous Small Firms Each seller’s output is tiny relative to total market supply. No
single farmer can raise the price by withholding a few sacks.
2. Price Taking Behavior Firms are price takers—they accept the market price as given.
Ravi sets his sacks at ₹2,000 only because he knows buyers will flock elsewhere if he
charges ₹2,050.
3. Homogeneous Products With identical wheat quality, branding plays no role. Buyers
focus solely on price, not reputation.
4. Free Entry and Exit When market prices rise above average costs, new farmers
venture in. If prices fall below costs, unprofitable farmers cease production.
5. Perfect Information Everyone knows current prices, input costs, and market demand.
Rumors of a bumper harvest or drought spread instantly, guiding decisions.
6. Zero Transport or Transaction Costs Farmers and buyers trade without extra fees,
ensuring price uniformity across the market.
The Firm’s Revenue Under Perfect Competition
Since each firm faces the market price (P) for every unit sold (Q), its revenue curves simplify:
• Average Revenue (AR) equals Price. AR = TR/Q = P.
• Marginal Revenue (MR), the revenue from selling one more unit, also equals Price.
MR = ΔTR/ΔQ = P.
Both AR and MR appear as horizontal lines at the market price level. For Ravi, each
additional quintal of wheat sold at ₹2,000 adds exactly ₹2,000 to his total revenue.
Short-Run Equilibrium of a Firm
In the short run, some costs (like rent on land or a permanent shed) are fixed, while others
(seeds, labor) vary with output. A farmer chooses output where profit peaks.
1. Profit Maximization Rule The firm produces up to the point where MR = MC
(marginal cost). Since MR = P in perfect competition, this becomes: P = MC.
2. Profit, Loss, or Break-Even
Easy2Siksha.com
o If P > average total cost (ATC) at that output, the firm earns positive
economic profit.
o If P = ATC, it breaks even (normal profit).
o If P lies between average variable cost (AVC) and ATC, the firm covers
variable costs and some fixed costs, incurring a controllable loss—better than
shutting down.
o If P < AVC, the firm shuts down immediately to minimize losses.
Story 1: Ravi’s Profit Calculation
Last season, wheat sold at ₹2,200 per quintal. Ravi’s marginal cost curve rose with output—
₹1,800 at 10 quintals, ₹2,200 at 12 quintals, and ₹2,600 at 14 quintals. Equating P to MC led
Ravi to produce 12 quintals. His average total cost at that output was ₹2,000, so he earned a
profit of ₹200 per quintal, totaling ₹2,400. When rains failed and price slipped to ₹1,900,
Ravi still produced 10 quintals because the ₹1,900 covered his AVC of ₹1,700, even though
he incurred a small loss on fixed costs—better than idling his land and equipment.
Long-Run Equilibrium of a Firm
In the long run, all costs become variable. Firms can adjust land, machinery, or even exit the
market. Two forces guide the market toward a stable state:
1. Free Entry and Exit
o At P > ATC, new farmers enter, increasing market supply, pushing P down.
o At P < ATC, some farmers exit, shrinking supply, pushing P up.
2. Zero Economic Profit The process continues until P = minimum ATC for the typical
firm. At this point: P = MC = minimum ATC.
No firm earns above-normal profit; they earn just enough to cover opportunity costs.
Resources in the industry are in their most efficient, cost-effective use.
Graphical Snapshot
• The horizontal line AR = MR = P represents the market price.
• MC curve cuts ATC at its minimum.
Easy2Siksha.com
• Equilibrium occurs at Q2 where P = MC = minimum ATC, yielding zero economic
profit in the long run.
Why Perfect Competition Matters
Although rare in its pure form, perfect competition serves as a benchmark:
• Efficiency: Firms produce at the lowest possible cost, and goods are allocated to
those who value them most.
• Consumer Welfare: Prices reflect true production costs, maximizing consumer
surplus.
• Entry Incentives: Zero barriers encourage innovation in input usage and cost
reduction.
Researchers and policymakers use this ideal to measure real-world deviations—like
monopolies or oligopolies—guiding regulation and competition policy.
Reflecting on Real Markets
True perfect competition is scarce—few industries have innumerable identical firms, free
entry, and perfect information. However:
• Agricultural Markets: Many small farmers often approximate this model, as with
Ravi’s wheat.
• Commodity Exchanges: Oil, metals, or grain futures markets feature price-taking
behaviour.
• Online Retail of Standardized Products: Certain digital marketplaces, where
identical e-books or software apps compete on price.
Concluding Thoughts
In the quiet dawn at Green Meadow Market, Ravi’s wheat sacks told a powerful economic
story. Perfect competition, with countless sellers vying at a single price, reveals how market
forces can drive firms to their profit-maximizing output in the short run and to zero
economic profit in the long run. While pure perfect competition remains an ideal,
understanding its mechanics illuminates the workings of real markets—helping students and
examiners alike appreciate the invisible threads that bind production, price, and profit in the
economic tapestry.
8. What is monopolistic competition? Explain the price and output determination under
monopolistic competition.
Ans: A Rainy Afternoon at Sweet Corner: Exploring Monopolistic Competition
It was pouring outside when Maya ducked into Sweet Corner, a cozy bakery tucked between
two fashion boutiques. Inside, a dozen small cake shops lined the street, each with its own
Easy2Siksha.com
twist on chocolate ganache and strawberry swirl. No two cake slices tasted exactly alike, yet
customers wandered from one shop to another, tempted by flavor, frosting design, or a
catchy store name. This lively scene captures the essence of monopolistic competition,
where many sellers vie for attention through product variety, price choices, and a sprinkle of
creativity.
Defining Monopolistic Competition
Monopolistic competition is a market structure that blends elements of perfect competition
and monopoly. Firms sell similar but differentiated products, granting each firm some
degree of price-making power. Key features include:
• Many small firms competing in a broad market.
• Product differentiation through branding, quality, design, or features.
• Some control over price, because a cake at Sweet Corner isn’t identical to one at
Berry Delights.
• Free entry and exit, allowing new bakeries to open when profits beckon and
unprofitable ones to close.
• Non-price competition—advertising, packaging, location, and customer service
matter as much as price.
This environment contrasts perfectly competitive wheat farmers, whose products are
indistinguishable, and pure monopolists, who face no close rivals.
How Firms Earn Revenue
In monopolistic competition, each firm’s demand curve slopes downward:
• Average Revenue (AR) declines as price rises because higher prices push some
customers to rival bakeries.
• Marginal Revenue (MR) lies below AR, because selling an extra cake requires
lowering the price on all cakes sold, reducing additional revenue.
Graphically, AR and MR both slope downward, with MR steeper. Firms decide output by
equating MR to Marginal Cost (MC), just as in other market structures.
Short-Run Price and Output Determination
In the short run, a bakery like Sweet Corner faces fixed costs (oven lease) and variable costs
(flour, eggs). It chooses output to maximize profit or minimize losses.
1. Profit Maximization Rule Produce where MR = MC. The firm then sets price using its
AR (demand) curve at that output.
2. Possibility of Supernormal Profit If the price at MR = MC exceeds Average Total Cost
(ATC), the firm earns positive economic profit. Maya’s bakery might earn extra if its
chocolate-mint swirl draws crowds willing to pay a premium.
Easy2Siksha.com
3. Break-Even or Loss If price equals ATC, the bakery breaks even. If price falls between
ATC and Average Variable Cost (AVC), it covers variable costs but incurs a partial loss
on fixed costs—still operating to reduce losses. If price drops below AVC, the bakery
shuts down immediately.
Visualizing Short-Run Equilibrium
• The firm identifies Q* where MR intersects MC.
• Price P* is read off the AR curve at Q*.
• Profit per unit equals P* minus ATC at Q; the shaded area between P and ATC
represents total profit.
Story 2: The Curious Case of Berry Delights
Across the street, Berry Delights introduced a new raspberry swirl that captivated health-
conscious students. Initially Maya’s profits soared, but when Chloe launched her low-sugar
berry cheesecake down the road, consumer foot traffic split. Sweet Corner’s management
realized they could counter by offering mini-cupcake samples and running an Instagram
contest. Despite fierce rivalry, each bakery found a sweet spot—adjusting price, flavors, and
marketing to suit niche tastes. This mini-drama illustrates how short-run profits emerge and
invite competition.
Long-Run Equilibrium Under Monopolistic Competition
Long-run dynamics differ because entry and exit adjust market supply of differentiated
products:
1. Entry Erodes Profits Supernormal profits lure new entrants. More cake shops spring
up, each offering a fresh flavor twist. The demand for any one bakery’s cakes
diminishes.
2. Zero Economic Profit As AR shifts leftward and MR follows, the firm’s demand curve
tangents its ATC at the profit-maximizing output. In the long run: MR = MC = ATC at
the tangency point. Price equals ATC, so economic profit is zero. The bakery covers
all costs, including opportunity cost, but no extra.
3. Excess Capacity Unlike perfect competition, price exceeds marginal cost (P > MC).
Firms don’t operate at minimum ATC; they produce less than the output that would
Easy2Siksha.com
minimize cost per unit. This leads to excess capacity—a hallmark inefficiency of
monopolistic competition.
Long-Run Graphical Overview
• The long-run AR’ curve is tangent to ATC’ at QLR.
• MR’ intersects MC at the same QLR, ensuring MR’ = MC.
• Price PLR (where AR’ sits above MC) equals ATC’, yielding zero economic profit.
Implications and Efficiency
Monopolistic competition strikes a balance:
• Consumers enjoy product variety and can choose based on flavour, packaging, or
brand ethos.
• Firms earn zero long-run profits but invest in innovation—new flavours, packaging
designs, loyalty programs.
• However, there’s allocative inefficiency (P > MC) and productive inefficiency (firms
don’t produce at minimum ATC). Resources might be over-allocated to varieties that
consumers don’t value as much relative to their cost.
Real-World Examples
• Fast Food Chains: Many burger joints with unique sauces, each facing its own
demand.
• Specialty Coffee Shops: Independent cafes differentiate through roast style,
ambiance, and barista skill.
• Clothing Brands: Small fashion labels offering distinct designs, fabrics, or sustainable
credentials.
Although not textbook perfect, these industries reflect monopolistic competition’s blend of
variety and rivalry.
Easy2Siksha.com
Conclusion
Monopolistic competition unfolds like Maya’s rainy-day adventure at Sweet Corner. Each
firm wields some price power by differentiating its product, yet competes fiercely enough to
drive short-run profits to zero in the long run. Students can picture AR and MR curving
downward, profit peaks where MR equals MC, and the long-run tangency of AR to ATC
erasing economic gains. This choreography of entry, exit, and product innovation makes
monopolistic competition a vibrant, if slightly inefficient, market scene—one that keeps
consumers delighted and bakers on their toes.
“This paper has been carefully prepared for educational purposes. If you notice any
mistakes or have suggestions, feel free to share your feedback.”
